First-hand information for everyone
Researchers built the world’s first public inventory of ownership for 9,761 digital news outlets in 77 countries, using data from Wikipedia and Wikidata. Using this inventory, they calculated traffic‑weighted Herfindahl–Hirschman Index (HHI) concentration scores for each country. The results show that media markets vary widely, with some nations dominated by a handful of owners and others more evenly split.

Applying the same ownership map to the ways AI systems cite news, the study compared AI‑citation concentration to ordinary audience traffic. Across seven AI models, including popular tools like Gemini, Copilot, and Google AI Overviews, the median amplification of concentration ranged from 1.23‑x to 2.08‑x. That is, for a given country, AI citations were concentrated on a narrower set of outlets than the outlets actually visited by readers.
| By outlet | By owner | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Data | Model | AI ÷ traffic HHI | nAI>traffic | AI ÷ traffic HHI | nAI>traffic |
| Ahrefs | Gemini | 2.08×*** [1.65, 2.56] | 65 / 76 | 1.79×*** [1.49, 2.00] | 47 / 53 |
| Copilot | 1.60×*** [1.38, 1.86] | 59 / 76 | 1.33×*** [1.13, 1.57] | 42 / 54 | |
| 1.57×*** [1.36, 1.73] | 60 / 76 | 1.34×** [1.14, 1.46] | 39 / 54 | ||
| ChatGPT | 1.35×*** [1.22, 1.63] | 61 / 76 | 1.33×*** [1.16, 1.58] | 41 / 54 | |
| Grok | 1.23×** [1.09, 1.38] | 51 / 76 | 1.11×* [1.02, 1.31] | 35 / 54 | |
| Arena | Perplexity | 1.76×*** [1.47, 1.95] | 23 / 31 | 1.19×* [0.99, 1.53] | 20 / 31 |
| Gemini | 1.70× [1.02, 2.70] | 13 / 17 | 1.28× [0.99, 1.67] | 12 / 16 | |
| GPT 4.0 | 1.60×* [1.23, 6.05] | 10 / 13 | 1.47×* [1.09, 1.73] | 10 / 13 | |
Because the AI amplification effect appears strongest in countries that already have lower traffic concentration, the results suggest that AI intermediaries can reinforce existing media dominance. However the study notes that the dataset covers only 28.8% of known news domains, and that reliance on Wikipedia‑based information may bias concentration estimates.
Visual 1 illustrates the traffic‑weighted HHI values per country, while Visual 2 (Table 2) details the amplification ratios for each AI system at both outlet and owner levels.